Summary

PCIe Gen4 Data Center NVMe drives challenge the existence of traditional SAS and SATA drives. This entry-level NVMe offering outperforms both SAS and SATA while retaining an affordable price that directly competes with SATA.

The purpose of this DfD is to educate readers on our new Gen4 Data Center NVMe offerings, including a brief history on the technology, a performance data comparison to SAS and SATA, and their value proposition in the market today. With this knowledge we hope our customers can make the best storage investment decision to optimize their PowerEdge servers.

NVMe Market Positioning

The NVMe host controller interface has been rapidly evolving since its inception less than a decade ago. By including high-performance, scalable technologies absent from both SAS and SATA interfaces, such as non-volatile (persistent) memory and the high-speed PCIe bus, NVMe was originally designed only as a premium storage offering and was priced to reflect that for several years. However, this novelty technology has become conventional. The shift inclined suppliers to optimize their processes to create more competitive price points. Now that the Gen4 Data Center NVMe drive has been introduced with both the high-performance and a more affordable price – is it time to start transitioning completely to NVMe?

 Figure 1 – Dell U.2 PCIe Gen4 NVMe SSD

Enterprise vs. Data Center NVMe

There are two classes of NVMe drives used in servers – Enterprise NVMe and Data Center NVMe SSD. Enterprise NVMe is the premium drive made for enterprise environments that run 24/7. This won’t be discussed, as its performance edge and enterprise features drive the price too high to compete with SAS and SATA at this time.

 Instead, we will be focusing on the Data Center NVMe SSD. This vSAN-certified NVMe drive is tailored for scale-out/hyperscale environments where enterprise features, such as dual port and FIPS support, are not needed for the Data Center customer. This more targeted feature set, coupled with a lower-cost eight-channel controller, enables a more attractive price comparable to SATA. This high performance (see Figure 2) and lower price-point creates a clear and distinctive value proposition for this class of NVMe drive.

Figure 2 – Performance comparison of PCIe Gen4 Enterprise and Data Center NVMe SSDs

When comparing identical capacities of enterprise and data center NVMe drives, we can see that most performance readouts are very similar to one another, at around ±10%. Outliers do seem to exist, but they favor both sides. This indicates that the DC NVMe SSD does not sacrifice any significant amount of performance for its ‘entry-level’ price tag, but primarily its enterprise features. Thus, Gen4 DC NVMe is an excellent NVMe option for users who do not require the enterprise features.

Comparing Performance and Pricing

Here is where it gets really interesting. Pricing for identical NVMe drives remain relatively constant with each new generation. In this case, both PCIe Gen3 and PCIe Gen4 DC NVMe are priced nearly one-to- one, despite seeing significant performance gains with support for PCIe Gen4. This begs for some due diligence – with higher performance at cost parity, will Gen4 DC NVMe now expunge any remaining value proposition that may justify still using SAS or SATA in your PowerEdge servers?

To answer this question, we must first scrutinize the performance data. Figure 3 below shows how the performance readouts stack up and helps us understand the variances (highlighted in orange).

Figure 3 – Table comparing read and write performance for three storage mediums (Gen4 DC NVMe, SAS, and SATA)

Gen4 DC NVMe outperforms its competitors by a longshot for every metric, with a performance increase multiplier ranging from:

• 1.7x - 5.8x when compared to SAS
• 2.2x - 13.3x when compared to SATA

The sequential and random read numbers for Gen4 DC NVMe are excellent as expected, and the write IOPs have significantly improved and are even approaching Enterprise Mixed Use (MU) NVMe IOPs. Additionally, the endurance has also doubled from 0.5 to 1 DWPD (Drive Writes Per Day).

Pricing comparisons are a bit more complex to discuss accurately because they are always shifting and very sensitive. So, for this exercise, we will determine relative pricing percentages for vendor-agnostic models from our Q4 2021 price list. If Gen4 DC NVMe drives are the baseline (1.0x), then for the same capacity you will see an average price multiplier of:

• 1.43x for SAS
• 0.77x for SATA

Based on this performance and pricing we can conclude that there is no benefit in choosing SAS over Gen4 DC NVMe, because it is both more expensive and has much lower performance.

All that is left to determine is the value proposition of SATA. As mentioned earlier, SATA drives are still the most affordable form of storage medium on the market, at around 0.77x the price of Gen4 DC NVMe. However, there is still a bigger picture to craft when the data is analyzed at a deeper level. By calculating the performance-per-dollar (IOPs/$) for each capacity of Gen4 DC NVMe and SATA, we can get a better grasp on how effective each dollar spent really is. See Figure 4 below:

When the data is analyzed at this level, it becomes very apparent that each dollar spent on Gen4 DC NVMe goes way farther than it does with SATA. In the case of random read performance, each dollar spent on SATA will produce 0.1x - 0.2x as many IOPs as Gen4 DC NVMe would. In layman’s terms, this means that every dollar spent on SATA is nearly an order of magnitude less effective than Gen4 DC NVMe!

Final Thoughts

Now that the data has been presented and analyzed we can circle back to the original question - is it time to start transitioning completely to NVMe? Based on the high performance and very attractive price point, we believe that the Data Center NVMe drive has a clear and compelling value proposition for PowerEdge customers looking to invest in a scalable, forward-looking storage medium. However, customers that prioritize the lowest price possible will also find SATA to be a valuable solution.

1. PCIe Gen4 Data Center NVMe is strongly recommended for most customer user cases. Budget-conscious customers should also consider that greater performance can be achieved at a lower price than SATA simply by scaling down the total number of Gen4 DC NVMe drives. With a performance output of up to 13.3x more than SATA while only being around 1.3x more expensive, customers can scale down the quantity of NVMe drives for the most cost-effective solution.
2. SATA is recommended to customers where the lowest price is most important. As long as SATA holds its extremely low price, there will always be a target audience for this storage type. Customers that neither intend to scale, nor require high-performance, may certainly find this to be the best solution for their needs.

In conclusion, while SATA technology still brings value to the market through its extremely low price point, PCIe Gen4 Data Center NVMe technology has demonstrated that it is certainly the most cost-effective storage solution from a price-per-performance metric. Customers also have more flexibility with the option to increase performance and lower price by scaling down the total number of NVMe drives! Regardless, PCIe Gen4 Data Center NVMe technology has proven that for the time being it offers unmatched value to PowerEdge servers.